Topics: Serious online harms, digital duty of care
Kieran Gilbert: Welcome back to NewsDay. Joining me live in the studio is the Shadow Minister for Communications and Digital Safety, Sarah Henderson. Thanks very much for your time. The Labor Party, we heard Julian Hill just before the break saying, urging the Coalition to come on board with the digital duty of care, saying that the campaign against it is misplaced. It’s not about censorship; it is about protecting young Australians from harm. Tanya Plibersek, in the last couple of days, with her social media push, has been saying digital duty of care is needed to stop things like deepfakes, other harassment online. Why is the coalition adamant you’re not going to come on board with it?
Senator Henderson: It’s appalling the lies that Labor MPs and senators are now talking in relation to the digital duty of care. Tanya Plibersek posted a social media video a couple of days ago saying we need these laws to prevent kids from seeing pornography, to combat child sexual abuse material. These are already prohibited under the law, both under the Criminal Code in some degrees, and also under the Online Safety Act, we have bipartisan support. And what the Labor Party is doing, shockingly, Kieran, all of the codes and standards which govern the very specific obligations on the platforms to remove and combat and deter this really serious online illegal material — that is all being stripped out of the Act. Even the eSafety Commissioner is saying that the powers under the proposed laws are weakened.
Kieran Gilbert: So why aren’t the platforms complying then? If it’s all against the law now, things like how to make a bomb and terrible material like that, how is that still online?
Senator Henderson: That is a huge issue, and that’s why I’m saying – why isn’t the government focusing on enforcing the current law, rather than imposing this broad duty on every online service? Whether you’re a mothers’ group running a blog, whether you’re a church group running a Facebook page, or a small business running a website, everyone is captured by this digital duty of care, and there are very vague, dangerously vague definitions of online harm, which means that the eSafety Commissioner and the minister will have wide-ranging powers to remove lawful speech.
Kieran Gilbert: So, you still believe it’s about political communication?
Senator Henderson: Absolutely, they are determined to pull down the material of their opponents, and that’s why there are such wide-ranging definitions, which even the eSafety Commissioner has called out.
Kieran Gilbert: So, you’re suspicious of that. What about the actual law enforcement component, though? What needs to happen to prevent that sort of appalling material from being online, whether it be threats to national security or threats to an individual’s safety, a young person who might be targeted?
Senator Henderson: This is shocking. There is some terrible online material which is illegal, like bomb-making videos. Why isn’t the government, the eSafety Commissioner, focused on that material, on getting that material down? If more laws are needed to combat that really serious material, then let’s have a look at that. I mean, we are up for the challenge of fixing our current laws …
Kieran Gilbert: Nudify technologies and things like that. Surely that’s against the law as well?
Senator Henderson: That is covered to a large degree in the current laws, which are the codes and standards which are enforceable, so this digital duty of care is all about shutting down free speech, shutting down the political opponents of Labor. I mean, the Prime Minister called this out and gave the game away in New York when he gave that speech, saying the digital duty of care is all about misinformation, disinformation, the polarisation of views on the left and the right. And the fact that they are trying to do things like stop material which is hostile to women or gender equality. What does that even mean? Even the eSafety Commissioner last week in our Senate hearing said that meaning needs to be decided by the Parliament because even she does not know what that means.
Kieran Gilbert: What about the approach to deciding your own feed, as opposed to being dictated to by algorithms? Do you support that element?
Senator Henderson: Look, the problem is that the Minister has given herself unfettered powers to make any rule in relation to user empowerment tools. She’s also decreed that any recommender system, even, you know, what’s used by Google Maps to guide people when they get lost, that it has dangerous negative connotations. So, they’ve got all of that wrong. I mean, there may well be a legitimate debate in relation to controlling one’s feed, but frankly, the powers in this bill go far beyond that. They are really dangerous. They give the Minister to control every aspect of an online service, and that is really dangerous. And that’s why we are pushing so hard against this bill.
Kieran Gilbert: I know. Well, you’ve got to get to the Senate. We’ll let you go. Thank you. Appreciate it.
Senator Henderson: Thanks, Kieran.